In a heartbreaking case that has gripped western Sydney, Paul Jason Sultana, a 35-year-old man, was found guilty of murdering 28-year-old Dayna Isaac, a beloved mother of two, on September 26, 2025. The brutal crime, driven by jealousy and rejection, took place in Dayna’s Penrith apartment in January 2023. The trial’s dramatic end, with Paul Jason Sultana stabbing himself in court, left everyone stunned. This tragedy highlights the dangers of domestic violence and the pain it leaves behind. Let’s dive into the details of this devastating story and what it means for the community.
The Crime That Sparked the Paul Jason Sultana Case
Paul Jason Sultana and Dayna Isaac had known each other for years, sharing a close friendship that briefly turned romantic. Dayna, known for her bright smile and lively spirit, was a devoted mother to her two young daughters. Friends described her as the “life of the party,” someone who lit up any room with her warmth and energy. But their relationship took a dark turn when Dayna made it clear she wanted to stay just friends. Paul Jason Sultana, unable to accept her decision, grew controlling and possessive.
On January 18, 2023, in Dayna’s apartment in Penrith, a suburb west of Sydney, Paul Jason Sultana strangled her with a cord. The attack was brutal and personal, fueled by his anger over her rejection. Just the day before, he had moved some of his belongings into her home, ignoring her wishes to keep their relationship platonic. Dayna’s father, Garry English, had even confronted him months earlier, saying firmly, “Paul, Dayna likes you as a friend and nothing more.” Despite these clear boundaries, Paul Jason Sultana’s obsession led to a horrific act that ended Dayna’s life and shattered her family.
After the murder, Paul Jason Sultana didn’t stop there. In a chilling move, he reached out to family members for help, asking them to assist in moving Dayna’s body. He drove his mother, Janet, to the apartment in Dayna’s own car. When she saw the scene, Janet fled in panic, shouting, “I’m gone, I’m out of here.” This desperate attempt to cover his tracks only added to the horror of the crime, showing a calculated side to Paul Jason Sultana’s actions.
The Trial of Paul Jason Sultana
The trial took place in the NSW Supreme Court, where Paul Jason Sultana faced a murder charge before Justice Peter Garling. He pleaded not guilty, spinning a story that seemed straight out of a bad movie. He claimed he was asleep on Dayna’s couch when an unknown person entered her apartment and killed her. According to him, he woke up to find her dead and had no role in the crime. But the evidence told a different story. Forensic tests found his DNA on Dayna’s clothes, her body, and the cord used to strangle her. The judge called his defense “not even a remote possibility,” pointing to the overwhelming proof that Paul Jason Sultana was the killer.
Throughout the trial, the courtroom was heavy with emotion. Dayna’s family, dressed in pink to honor her memory, sat through painful testimony about her final moments. They heard how Paul Jason Sultana’s jealousy and refusal to respect her boundaries led to her death. For them, the guilty verdict was a bittersweet moment—a step toward justice for their “princess,” as her father called her, but a reminder of the loss they could never undo.
Chaos After the Verdict
The trial’s climax came on September 26, 2025, when the jury delivered the guilty verdict. What should have been a moment of closure turned into chaos. As soon as the word “guilty” echoed in the courtroom, Paul Jason Sultana broke down. Sobbing loudly, he suddenly pulled out a sharp object and stabbed himself in the left arm. Blood poured from the wound, shocking everyone in the room. Sheriff’s officers rushed to restrain him, and paramedics scrambled to stop the bleeding. Instead of being led to a prison van, Paul Jason Sultana was wheeled out on a stretcher, heading to a hospital for treatment.
The scene left Dayna’s family, already grieving, in a state of disbelief. Court staff, who witnessed the violent outburst, were offered support to cope with the trauma. An investigation into how Paul Jason Sultana smuggled a sharp object into the courtroom is now underway, raising questions about security. For those present, the image of a bloodied Paul Jason Sultana was a haunting end to an already tragic case.
The Bigger Picture: Domestic Violence in Focus
The Paul Jason Sultana case is more than a single crime—it’s a stark reminder of the dangers of intimate partner violence. In Australia, too many women like Dayna lose their lives to partners or ex-partners who can’t handle rejection or loss of control. Dayna was a vibrant young woman, raising two little girls who now face life without their mother. Her story underscores the need for better awareness and prevention of domestic violence. Warning signs, like controlling behavior or ignoring boundaries, can escalate into deadly outcomes if ignored.
The community in Penrith and beyond has rallied around Dayna’s memory. Social media posts have shared tributes to her, celebrating her love for her daughters and her infectious joy. Meanwhile, Paul Jason Sultana’s actions have sparked anger and calls for justice. His sentencing is still to come, and it will likely bring more attention to the case. For now, Dayna’s family is focused on healing and ensuring her daughters grow up knowing how much their mother loved them.
Why the Paul Jason Sultana Case Matters
This case has struck a chord because it touches on issues that hit close to home for many. It’s about love turning toxic, about the pain of losing someone to violence, and about a community grappling with how to prevent such tragedies. Paul Jason Sultana’s guilty verdict is a step toward accountability, but it can’t bring Dayna back. Her family hopes her story will inspire others to speak out about domestic violence and seek help before it’s too late.https://www.news.com.au/
As Sydney reflects on this case, questions linger. How can we better protect women like Dayna? What can be done to stop men like Paul Jason Sultana before they harm others? These are tough questions, but they’re ones we need to keep asking.
What do you think about this heartbreaking case? How can we work to prevent domestic violence in our communities? Share your thoughts in the comments below.Arts and Entertainment
This news blog is based on court events as of September 26, 2025.
1 thought on “Paul Jason Sultana: A Guilty Verdict and Courtroom Chaos Shakes Sydney”